Automatic vs. Manual Raise Arm Barriers

Raise arm barriers, also known as boom barriers, are a popular solution for this purpose.

These barriers are available in two main types; automatic and manual. Each has its own advantages and disadvantages, enabling them to be suitable for different scenarios.

In this blog, we’ll look at the key features, benefits and drawbacks of both automatic and manual raise arm barriers so that you can decide which would work best for you.

Automatic Raise Arm Barriers

Key Features

Automatic raise arm barriers provide an automated and secure point of access for vehicles entering and exiting your site. Commonly found in car parks to prevent unauthorised access to industrial sites.

Benefits

1. Convenience and Efficiency

Automatic barriers provide a high level of convenience as they can be operated without manual intervention. This is particularly beneficial in high-traffic areas where efficient access is needed.

1. Enhanced Security

These barriers feature a programmable control panel within the main base of the barrier in order to be programmed for multiple factors depending on your site requirements.

1. Remote Operation

Automatic barriers can be controlled remotely, making them ideal for locations where on-site staff might not be present at all times.

1. Durability and Reliability

High quality automatic barriers are designed to withstand heavy use and harsh weather, making them a reliable choice for long-term use.

1. Easy Installation

These barriers are quick and easy to install on your premises, making site access easier, quicker.

Drawbacks

1. Higher Initial Cost

The advanced technology and capabilities of automatic barriers come at a higher initial cost in comparison to manual barriers

1. Maintenance Requirements

These barriers would require regular maintenance to ensure that the motor and control systems are functioning correctly.

1. Power Supply

Automatic barriers require a consistent power supply to operate, which can be a limitation in some areas.

Manual Raise Arm Barriers

Key Features

Manual raise arm barriers are suitable for restricting traffic from entering a site or preventing access for security purposes. These are ideal in public and private car parks which may be open during the day and closed at night. As standard the arms are able to be locked in the opened or closed position for additional security.

Benefits

1. Cost-Effective

Manual barriers are generally less expensive to purchase and install, making them a cost-effective option for low-traffic areas or sites with a smaller budget.

1. Low Maintenance

With fewer moving parts and no electrical components, manual barriers require minimal maintenance.

1. Simplicity

The straightforward design of manual barriers makes them easy to operate and repair if needed.

1. Independence from Power Supply

As they don’t rely on electricity, manual barriers are ideal for remote locations or areas with an unstable power supply.

1. Durability

Manufactured from high quality materials, the manual arm barriers are able to withstand a range of weather conditions, and with additional powder coating can protect against corrosion and rust.

Drawbacks

1. Manual Operation

The need for a manual operation can be inconvenient, especially in high-traffic areas or for users with physical limitations.

1. Limited Security Features

Manual barriers cannot be integrated with advanced access control systems, which may limit their effectiveness in high-security areas.

1. Potential for Human Error

Since manual barriers rely on human operation, there is a greater chance for errors, such as forgetting to lower the barrier after entry or exit.

Choosing the Right Barrier

The decision between automatic and manual raise arm barriers depends on your specific requirements. Consider the following when making your decision:

1. Traffic Volume – for high traffic areas such as busy car parks or commercial properties, then automatic barriers might be better to help manage large volumes of vehicles.

1. Security Requirements – if your main secure is security and controlled access then automatic barriers will provide a higher level of protection.

1. Budget – Budget constraints can play a significant role in deciding which barrier to go for.

1. Location – where is the barrier going? For remote areas with unreliable power supplies, manual arm barriers might be the better option.

Conclusion

Automatic and manual raise arm barriers have their own unique advantages and disadvantages. Understanding your requirements, budget and the environment will help you make the right decision for your site.

Learn more about our automatic and manual arm barriers here.